Meaning Is Healthier Than Happiness
People who are happy but have little-to-no sense of meaning in
their lives have the same gene expression patterns as people who are
enduring chronic adversity.
"Being happy is about feeling good. Meaning is derived from contributing to others or to society in a bigger way. Meaning was defined as an orientation to something bigger than the self. "
For at least the last decade, the happiness craze has been building.
In the last three months alone, over 1,000 books on happiness were
released on Amazon, including Happy Money, Happy-People-Pills For All, and, for those just starting out, Happiness for Beginners.
One of the consistent claims of books like
these is that happiness is associated with all sorts of good life
outcomes, including — most promisingly — good health. Many studies have noted the connection between a happy mind and a healthy body — the
happier you are, the better health outcomes we seem to have. In a
meta-analysis (overview) of 150 studies on this topic, researchers put
it like this: “Inductions of well-being lead to healthy functioning, and
inductions of ill-being lead to compromised health.”
But a new study, just published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) challenges the rosy picture. Happiness may not be as good for the body as researchers thought. It might even be bad.
Of course, it’s important to first define happiness. A few months ago, I wrote a piece called “There’s More to Life Than Being Happy” about a psychology study
that dug into what happiness really means to people. It specifically
explored the difference between a meaningful life and a happy life.
It seems strange that there would be a
difference at all. But the researchers, who looked at a large sample of
people over a month-long period, found that happiness is associated with
selfish “taking” behavior and that having a sense of meaning in life is associated with selfless “giving” behavior.
"Happiness without meaning characterizes a
relatively shallow, self-absorbed or even selfish life, in which things
go well, needs and desire are easily satisfied, and difficult or taxing
entanglements are avoided," the authors of the study wrote. "If
anything, pure happiness is linked to not helping others in need.” While
being happy is about feeling good, meaning is derived from contributing
to others or to society in a bigger way. As Roy Baumeister, one of the
researchers, told me, "Partly what we do as human beings is to take care
of others and contribute to others. This makes life meaningful but it
does not necessarily make us happy.”
The new PNAS study also sheds light on the
difference between meaning and happiness, but on the biological level.
Barbara Fredrickson, a psychological researcher who specializes in
positive emotions at the University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill, and
Steve Cole, a genetics and psychiatric researcher at UCLA, examined the
self-reported levels of happiness and meaning in 80 research subjects.
Happiness was defined, as in the earlier study, by feeling good.
The researchers measured happiness by asking subjects questions like
“How often did you feel happy?” “How often did you feel interested in
life?” and “How often did you feel satisfied?” The more strongly people
endorsed these measures of “hedonic well-being,” or pleasure, the higher
they scored on happiness.
Meaning was defined as an orientation to
something bigger than the self. They measured meaning by asking
questions like “How often did you feel that your life has a sense of
direction or meaning to it?”, “How often did you feel that you had
something to contribute to society?”, and “How often did you feel that
you belonged to a community/social group?” The more people endorsed
these measures of “eudaimonic well-being” — or, simply put, virtue — the more meaning they felt in life.
After noting the sense of meaning and happiness
that each subject had, Fredrickson and Cole, with their research
colleagues, looked at the ways certain genes expressed themselves in
each of the participants. Like neuroscientists who use fMRI scanning to
determine how regions in the brain respond to different stimuli, Cole
and Fredrickson are interested in how the body, at the genetic level,
responds to feelings of happiness and meaning.
Cole’s past work has linked various kinds of
chronic adversity to a particular gene expression pattern. When people
feel lonely, are grieving the loss of a loved one, or are struggling to
make ends meet, their bodies go into threat mode. This triggers the
activation of a stress-related gene pattern
that has two features: an increase in the activity of proinflammatory
genes and a decrease in the activity of genes involved in anti-viral
responses.
“You have a forward-looking immune system,”
Fredrickson told me, “If you have a long track record of adversity, it
prepares you for bacterial infections. For our ancestors, loneliness and
adversity were associated with bacterial infections from wounds with
predators and fights with conspecifics.” On the other hand, if you are
doing well and having a lot of healthy social connections, your immune
system shifts forward to prepare you for viruses, which you’re more
likely to contract if you're interacting with a lot of people.
What does this have to do with happiness?
Cole and Fredrickson found that people who are happy but have little to no sense of meaning in their lives — proverbially, simply here for the party — have
the same gene expression patterns as people who are responding to and
enduring chronic adversity. That is, the bodies of these happy people
are preparing them for bacterial threats by activating the
pro-inflammatory response. Chronic inflammation is, of course,
associated with major illnesses like heart disease and various cancers.
“Empty positive emotions” — like the kind people experience during manic episodes or artificially induced euphoria from alcohol and drugs — ”are about as good for you for as adversity,” says Fredrickson.
It’s important to understand that for many
people, a sense of meaning and happiness in life overlap; many people
score jointly high (or jointly low) on the happiness and meaning
measures in the study. But for many others, there is a dissonance — they
feel that they are low on happiness and high on meaning or that their
lives are very high in happiness, but low in meaning. This last group,
which has the gene expression pattern associated with adversity, formed a
whopping 75 percent of study participants. Only one quarter of the
study participants had what the researchers call “eudaimonic
predominance” — that is, their sense of meaning outpaced their feelings of happiness.
This is too bad given the more beneficial gene
expression pattern associated with meaningfulness. People whose levels
of happiness and meaning line up, and people who have a strong sense of
meaning but are not necessarily happy, showed a deactivation of the
adversity stress response. Their bodies were not preparing them for the
bacterial infections that we get when we are alone or in trouble, but
for the viral infections we get when surrounded by a lot of other
people.
Fredrickson’s past research, described in her two books, Positivity and Love 2.0,
has mapped the benefits of positive emotions in individuals. She has
found that positive emotions broaden a person’s perspective and buffers people against adversity.
So it was surprising to her that hedonistic well-being, which is
associated with positive emotions and pleasure, did so badly in this
study compared with eudaimonic well-being.
“It’s not the amount of hedonic happiness
that’s a problem,” Fredrickson tells me, “It’s that it’s not matched by
eudaimonic well-being. It’s great when both are in step. But if you have
more hedonic well-being than would be expected, that’s when this [gene]
pattern that’s akin to adversity emerged.”
The terms hedonism and eudaimonism bring to
mind the great philosophical debate, which has shaped Western
civilization for over 2,000 years, about the nature of the good life.
Does happiness lie in feeling good, as hedonists think, or in doing and
being good, as Aristotle and his intellectual descendants, the virtue
ethicists, think? From the evidence of this study, it seems that feeling
good is not enough. People need meaning to thrive. In the words of Carl
Jung, “The least of things with a meaning is worth more in life than
the greatest of things without it.” Jung’s wisdom certainly seems to
apply to our bodies, if not also to our hearts and our minds.
No comments:
Post a Comment