Abstract
Over
500 million people interact daily with Facebook. Yet, whether Facebook
use influences subjective well-being over time is unknown. We addressed
this issue using experience-sampling, the most reliable method for
measuring in-vivo behavior and psychological experience. We
text-messaged people five times per day for two-weeks to examine how
Facebook use influences the two components of subjective well-being: how
people feel moment-to-moment and how satisfied they are with their
lives. Our results indicate that Facebook use predicts negative shifts
on both of these variables over time. The more people used Facebook at
one time point, the worse they felt the next time we text-messaged them;
the more they used Facebook over two-weeks, the more their life
satisfaction levels declined over time. Interacting with other people
“directly” did not predict these negative outcomes. They were also not
moderated by the size of people's Facebook networks, their perceived
supportiveness, motivation for using Facebook, gender, loneliness,
self-esteem, or depression. On the surface, Facebook provides an
invaluable resource for fulfilling the basic human need for social
connection. Rather than enhancing well-being, however, these findings
suggest that Facebook may undermine it.
Citation: Kross E, Verduyn
P, Demiralp E, Park J, Lee DS, et al. (2013) Facebook Use Predicts
Declines in Subjective Well-Being in Young Adults. PLoS ONE 8(8):
e69841.
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0069841
Editor: Cédric Sueur, Institut Pluridisciplinaire Hubert Curien, France
Received: January 31, 2013; Accepted: June 12, 2013; Published: August 14, 2013
Copyright:
© 2013 Kross et al. This is an open-access article distributed under
the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided
the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The authors have no support or funding to report.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Online
social networks are rapidly changing the way human beings interact.
Over a billion people belong to Facebook, the world's largest online
social network, and over half of them log in daily
[1].
Yet, no research has examined how interacting with Facebook influences
subjective well-being over time. Indeed, a recent article that examined
every peer-reviewed publication and conference proceeding on Facebook
between 1/2005 and 1/2012 (412 in total) did not reveal a single study
that examined how using this technology influences subjective well-being
over time (
Text S1)
[2].
Subjective
well-being is one of the most highly studied variables in the
behavioral sciences. Although significant in its own right, it also
predicts a range of consequential benefits including enhanced health and
longevity
[3]–
[5].
Given the frequency of Facebook usage, identifying how interacting with
this technology influences subjective well-being represents a basic
research challenge that has important practical implications.
This
issue is particularly vexing because prior research provides mixed
clues about how Facebook use should influence subjective well-being.
Whereas some cross-sectional research reveals positive associations
between online social network use (in particular Facebook) and
well-being
[6], other work reveals the opposite
[7],
[8].
Still other work suggests that the relationship between Facebook use
and well-being may be more nuanced and potentially influenced by
multiple factors including number of Facebook friends, perceived
supportiveness of one's online network, depressive symptomatology,
loneliness, and self-esteem
[9],
[10],
[11].
So,
how does Facebook usage influence subjective well-being over time? The
cross-sectional approach used in previous studies makes it impossible to
know. We addressed this issue by using experience-sampling, the most
reliable method for measuring in-vivo behavior and psychological
experience over time
[12].
We text-messaged participants five times per day for 14-days. Each
text-message contained a link to an online survey, which participants
completed using their smartphones. We performed lagged analyses on
participants' responses, as well as their answers to the Satisfaction
With Life Questionnaire (SWLS)
[13],
which they completed before and immediately following the 14-day
experience-sampling period, to examine how interacting with Facebook
influences the two components of subjective well-being: how people feel
(“affective” well-being) and how satisfied they are with their lives
(“cognitive” well-being)
[14],
[15].
This approach allowed us to take advantage of the relative timing of
participants' natural Facebook behavior and psychological states to draw
inferences about their likely causal sequence
[16]–
[19].
Methods
Participants
Eighty-two people (
Mage = 19.52,
SDage
= 2.17; 53 females; 60.5% European American, 28.4% Asian, 6.2% African
American, and 4.9% other) were recruited for a study on Facebook through
flyers posted around Ann Arbor, Michigan. Participants needed a
Facebook account and a touch-screen smartphone to qualify for the study.
They received $20 and were entered into a raffle to receive an iPad2
for participating.
Ethics Statement
The
University of Michigan Institutional Review Board approved this study.
Informed written consent was obtained from all participants prior to
participation.
Materials and Procedure
Phase 1.
Participants completed a set of questionnaires, which included the SWLS (
M = 4.96,
SD = 1.17), Beck Depression Inventory
[20] (
M = 9.02,
SD = 7.20), the Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale
[21] (
M = 30.40,
SD = 4.96), and the Social Provision Scale
[22] (
M = 3.55,
SD
= .34), which we modified to assess perceptions of Facebook support. We
also assessed participants' motivation for using Facebook by asking
them to indicate whether they use Facebook “to keep in touch with
friends (98% answered yes),” “to find new friends (23% answered yes),”
“to share good things with friends (78% answered yes),” “to share bad
things with friends (36% answered yes),” “to obtain new information (62%
answered yes),” or “other: please explain (17% answered yes).” Examples
of other reasons included chatting with others, keeping in touch with
family, and facilitating schoolwork and business.
Phase 2.
Participants
were text-messaged 5 times per day between 10am and midnight over
14-days. Text-messages occurred at random times within 168-minute
windows per day. Each text-message contained a link to an online survey,
which asked participants to answer five questions using a slider scale:
(1) How do you feel right now? (
very positive [0] to
very negative [100];
M = 37.47,
SD = 25.88); (2) How worried are you right now? (
not at all [0] to
a lot [100];
M = 44.04,
SD = 30.42); (3) How lonely do you feel right now? (
not at all [0] to
a lot [100];
M = 27.61,
SD = 26.13); (4) How much have you used Facebook since the last time we asked? (
not at all [0] to
a lot [100];
M = 33.90,
SD = 30.48); (5) How much have you interacted with other people “directly” since the last time we asked? (
not at all [0]to
a lot [100];
M = 64.26,
SD
= 31.11). When the protocol for answering these questions was
explained, interacting with other people “directly” was defined as
face-to-face or phone interactions. An experimenter carefully walked
participants through this protocol to ensure that they understood how to
answer each question and fulfill the study requirements.
Participants
always answered the affect question first. Next the worry and
loneliness questions were presented in random order. The Facebook use
and direct social interaction questions were always administered last,
again in random order. Our analyses focused primarily on affect (rather
than worry and loneliness) because this affect question is the way
“affective well-being” is typically operationalized.
Phase 3.
Participants returned to the laboratory following Phase 2 to complete another set of questionnaires, which included the SWLS (
M = 5.13,
SD = 1.26) and the Revised UCLA Loneliness Scale
[23] (
M = 1.69,
SD = .46). Participants' number of Facebook friends (
M = 664.25,
SD = 383.64) was also recorded during this session from participants' Facebook accounts (
Text S2).
Results
Attrition and compliance
Three
participants did not complete the study. As the methods section notes,
participants received a text message directing them to complete a block
of five questions once every 168 minutes on average (the text message
was delivered randomly within this 168-minute window). A response to any
question within a block was considered “compliant” if it was answered
before
participants received a subsequent text-message directing them to
complete the next block of questions. Participants responded to an
average of 83.6% of text-messages (range: 18.6%–100%). Following prior
research
[24],
we pruned the data by excluding all of the data from two participants
who responded to <33% of the texts, resulting in 4,589 total
observations. The results did not change substantively when additional
cutoff rates were used.
Analyses overview
We
examined the relationship between Facebook use and affect using
multilevel analyses to account for the nested data structure.
Specifically, we examined whether T
2 affect (i.e., How do you feel
right now?) was predicted by T
1–2 Facebook use (i.e., How much have you used Facebook
since the last time we asked?), controlling for T
1 affect at level-1 of the model (between-day lags were excluded). Note that although this analysis assesses Facebook use at T
2, the question refers to usage between T
1 and T
2 (hence the notationT
1–2). This analysis allowed us to explore whether Facebook use during the time period separating T
1 and T
2 predicted changes in affect over this time span.
When
non-compliant cases were observed, we used participants' responses to
the last text message they answered to examine the lagged effect of
Facebook use on well-being to maximize power. So, if we were interested
in examining whether T
2–3 Facebook use predicted T
3 Affect controlling for T
2 Affect, but did not have data on T
2 Affect, then we used T
1
Affect instead. Excluding trials in which participants did not respond
to the previous texts (rather than following the aforementioned
analytical scheme) did not substantively alter any of the results we
report.
Significance
testing of fixed effects was performed using chi-squared distributed
(df = 1) Wald-tests. All level-1 predictors were group-mean centered,
and intercepts and slopes were allowed to vary randomly across
participants (see
Table 1
for zero-order correlations). We tested for moderation by examining
whether each moderator variable was related to the slope of T
1–2 Facebook use when predicting T
2 affect, controlling for T
1 affect.
Table 1. Within-person and between-person zero-order correlations.
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0069841.t001
Data from one person who scored 4SDs above the sample mean on the BDI
were excluded from the BDI moderation analyses; data from one person
who scored 4SDs above the sample mean on number of Facebook friends were
excluded from the moderation analyses based on Facebook friends.
The
relationship between mean Facebook use and life satisfaction was
assessed using OLS regressions because these data were not nested. Both
unstandardized (
B) and standardized (
β) OLS regression coefficients are reported (see
Text S3).
Facebook use and well-being
Affective well-being.
We
examined whether people's tendency to interact with Facebook during the
time period separating two text messages influenced how they felt at T
2, controlling for how they felt at T
1. Nested time-lag analyses indicated that the more people used Facebook the worse they subsequently felt,
B = .08,
χ2 = 28.90,
p<.0001, (see
Figure 1, top). The reverse pathway (T
1 Affect predicting T
1–2 Facebook use, controlling for T
0–1 Facebook use) was not significant,
B = −.005,
χ2 = .05,
p = .82, indicating that people do not use Facebook more or less depending on how they feel (see
Text S4,
S5).
Figure 1. Facebook use predicts declines in affect and life satisfaction over time.
Interacting with Facebook during one time period (Time
1–2) leads people to feel worse later on during the same day (T
2) controlling for how they felt initially (T
1);
values are regression weights from multilevel analyses (Panel A).
Average Facebook use over the course of the 14-day experience-sampling
period predicts decreases in life satisfaction over time; values are
standardized regression weights from OLS regression analysis (Panel B). *
p<.05, **
p<.01, ***
p<.001.
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0069841.g001
Cognitive well-being.
To
examine how Facebook use influenced “cognitive well-being,” we analyzed
whether people's average Facebook use over the 14-day period predicted
their life satisfaction at the end of the study, controlling for
baseline life satisfaction and average emotion levels over the 14-day
period. The more participants used Facebook, the more their life
satisfaction levels declined over time,
B = −.012,
β = −.124,
t(73) = −2.39,
p = .02, (see
Figure 1, bottom).
Alternative explanations.
An
alternative explanation for these results is that any form of social
interaction undermines well-being. Because we also asked people to
indicate how frequently they interacted with other people “directly”
since the last time we text messaged them, we were able to test this
idea. Specifically, we repeated each of the aforementioned analyses
substituting “direct” social interaction for Facebook use. In contrast
to Facebook use, “direct” social interaction did not predict changes in
cognitive well-being,
B = −.006,
β = −.059,
t(73) = 1.04,
p = .30, and predicted
increases (not decreases) in affective well-being,
B = −.15,
χ2 = 65.30,
p<.0001.
Controlling for direct social interaction did not substantively alter
the significant relationship between Facebook use and affective
well-being,
B = .05,
χ2 = 10.78,
p<.01.
Another
alternative explanation for these results is that people use Facebook
when they feel bad (i.e., when they are bored lonely, worried or
otherwise distressed), and feeling bad leads to declines in well-being
rather than Facebook use per se. The analyses we reported earlier
partially address this issue by demonstrating that affect does not
predict changes in Facebook use over time and Facebook use continues to
significantly predict declines in life satisfaction over time when
controlling for affect. However, because participants also rated how
lonely and worried they felt each time we text messaged them, we were
able to test this proposal further.
We first examined whether worry or loneliness predicted changes in Facebook use over time (i.e., T
1 worry [or T
1 loneliness] predicting T
1–2 Facebook use, controlling for T
0–1 Facebook use). Worry did not predict changes in Facebook use,
B = .04,
χ2 = 2.37,
p = .12, but loneliness did,
B = .07,
χ2 = 8.54,
p<.01.
The more lonely people felt at one time point, the more people used
Facebook over time. Given this significant relationship, we next
examined whether controlling for loneliness renders the relationship
between Facebook use and changes in affective and cognitive well-being
non-significant—what one would predict if Facebook use is a proxy for
loneliness. This was not the case. Facebook use continued to predict
declines in affective well-being,
B = .08,
χ2 = 27.87,
p<.0001, and cognitive well-being,
B = −.012,
β = −.126,
t(72) = 2.34,
p
= .02, when loneliness was controlled for in each analysis. Neither
worry nor loneliness interacted significantly with Facebook use to
predict changes in affective or cognitive well-being (
ps>.44).
Moderation.
Next,
we examined whether a number of theoretically relevant
individual-difference variables including participants' number of
Facebook Friends, their perceptions of their Facebook network support,
depressive symptoms, loneliness, gender, self-esteem, time of study
participation, and motivation for using Facebook (e.g., to find new
friends, to share good or bad things, to obtain new information)
interacted with Facebook use to predict changes in affective or
cognitive well-being (
Text S6). In no case did we observe any significant interactions (
ps>.16).
Exploratory analyses.
Although we did not have
a priori
predictions about whether Facebook use and direct social contact would
interact to predict changes in affective and cognitive well-being, we
nevertheless explored this issue in our final set of analyses. The
results of these analyses indicated that Facebook use and direct social
contact interacted significantly to predict changes in affective
well-being,
B = .002,
χ2 = 19.55,
p<.0001, but not changes in cognitive well-being,
B = .000,
β = .129,
t(71) = .39,
p
= .70. To understand the meaning of the former interaction, we
performed simple slope analyses. These analyses indicated that the
relationship between Facebook use and declines in affective well-being
increased linearly with direct social contact. Specifically, whereas
Facebook use did not predict significant declines in affective
well-being when participants experienced low levels of direct social
contact (i.e., 1 standard deviation below the sample mean for direct
social contact; B = .00, χ
2 = .04, p = .84), it did predict
significant declines in well-being when participants experienced
moderate levels of direct social contact (i.e., at the sample mean for
direct social contact; B = .05, χ
2 = 11.21, p<.001) and
high levels of direct social contact (i.e., 1 standard deviation above
the sample mean for direct social contact; B = .10, χ
2 = 28.82, p<.0001).
Discussion
Within
a relatively short timespan, Facebook has revolutionized the way people
interact. Yet, whether using Facebook predicts changes in subjective
well-being over time is unknown. We addressed this issue by performing
lagged analyses on experience sampled data, an approach that allowed us
to take advantage of the relative timing of participants' naturally
occurring behaviors and psychological states to draw inferences about
their likely causal sequence
[17],
[18].
These analyses indicated that Facebook use predicts declines in the two
components of subjective well-being: how people feel moment to moment
and how satisfied they are with their lives.
Critically,
we found no evidence to support two plausible alternative
interpretations of these results. First, interacting with other people
“directly” did not predict declines in well-being. In fact, direct
social network interactions led people to feel
better over
time. This suggests that Facebook use may constitute a unique form of
social network interaction that predicts impoverished well-being.
Second, multiple types of evidence indicated that it was not the case
that Facebook use led to declines in well-being because people are more
likely to use Facebook when they feel bad—neither affect nor worry
predicted Facebook use and Facebook use continued to predict significant
declines in well-being when controlling for loneliness (which did
predict increases in Facebook use and reductions in emotional
well-being).
Would
engaging in any solitary activity similarly predict declines in
well-being? We suspect that they would not because people often derive
pleasure from engaging in some solitary activities (e.g., exercising,
reading). Supporting this view, a number of recent studies indicate that
people's
perceptions of social isolation (i.e., how lonely
they feel)—a variable that we assessed in this study, which did not
influence our results—are a more powerful determinant of well-being than
objective social isolation
[25].
A related question concerns whether engaging in any Internet activity
(e.g., email, web surfing) would likewise predict well-being declines.
Here too prior research suggests that it would not. A number of studies
indicate that whether interacting with the Internet predicts changes in
well-being depends on how you use it (i.e., what sites you visit) and
who you interact with
[26].
Future research
Although
these findings raise numerous future research questions, four stand out
as most pressing. First, do these findings generalize? We concentrated
on young adults in this study because they represent a core Facebook
user demographic. However, examining whether these findings generalize
to additional age groups is important. Future research should also
examine whether these findings generalize to other online social
networks. As a recent review of the Facebook literature indicated
[2]
“[different online social networks] have varied histories and are
associated with different patterns of use, user characteristics, and
social functions (p. 205).” Therefore, it is possible that the current
findings may not neatly generalize to other online social networks.
Second,
what mechanisms underlie the deleterious effects of Facebook usage on
well-being? Some researchers have speculated that online social
networking may interfere with physical activity, which has cognitive and
emotional replenishing effects
[27] or trigger damaging social comparisons
[8],
[28].
The latter idea is particularly interesting in light of the significant
interaction we observed between direct social contact and Facebook use
in this study—i.e., the more people interacted with other people
directly, the more strongly Facebook use predicted declines in their
affective well-being. If harmful social comparisons explain how Facebook
use predicts declines in affective well-being, it is possible that
interacting with other people directly either enhances the frequency of
such comparisons or magnifies their emotional impact. Examining whether
these or other mechanisms explain the relationship between Facebook
usage and well-being is important both from a basic science and
practical perspective.
Finally,
although the analytic approach we used in this study is useful for
drawing inferences about the likely causal ordering of associations
between naturally occurring variables, experiments that manipulate
Facebook use in daily life are needed to corroborate these findings and
establish definitive causal relations. Though potentially challenging to
perform—Facebook use prevalence, its centrality to young adult daily
social interactions, and addictive properties may make it a difficult
intervention target—such studies are important for extending this work
and informing future interventions.
Caveats
Two
caveats are in order before concluding. First, although we observed
statistically significant associations between Facebook usage and
well-being, the sizes of these effects were relatively “small.” This
should not, however, undermine their practical significance
[29].
Subjective well-being is a multiply determined outcome—it is
unrealistic to expect any single factor to powerfully influence it.
Moreover, in addition to being consequential in its own right,
subjective well-being predicts an array of mental and physical health
consequences. Therefore, identifying any factor that systematically
influences it is important, especially when that factor is likely to
accumulate over time among large numbers of people. Facebook usage would
seem to fit both of these criteria.
Second,
some research suggests that asking people to indicate how good or bad
they feel using a single bipolar scale, as we did in this study, can
obscure interesting differences regarding whether a variable leads
people to feel less positive, more negative or both less positive and
more negative. Future research should administer two unipolar affect
questions to assess positive and negative affect separately to address
this issue.
Concluding Comment
The human need for social connection is well established, as are the benefits that people derive from such connections
[30]–
[34].
On the surface, Facebook provides an invaluable resource for fulfilling
such needs by allowing people to instantly connect. Rather than
enhancing well-being, as frequent interactions with supportive “offline”
social networks powerfully do, the current findings demonstrate that
interacting with Facebook may predict the opposite result for young
adults—it may undermine it.